Reservations with your name
"Confirmed flight (roundtrip)/travel reservations with the name of passenger", plus confirmed hotel reservations giving the hotel's name, address and phone number, as part of a detailed itinerary.
Insurance: the card isn't proof
The policy must name you and show at least €30,000 of cover, and "Employment letter and insurance cards are not accepted as proof of coverage". Bring the policy certificate.
Compare
Italy's San Francisco consulate and Spain's Washington consulate publish their own US checklists (compare all three).