St Helena: ticket or the money for one
For a short-term entry permit (up to 183 days, available on arrival), GOV.UK lists "a return ticket or proof of funds to buy one", plus accommodation. That's a genuine alternative: a recent bank statement showing enough for the fare can stand in for the ticket.
Ascension: a return ticket, no alternative
Ascension needs a visa, single-entry for up to 3 months, and GOV.UK lists a return ticket and accommodation, with no funds alternative.
Tristan da Cunha: permission first
You need permission from the Island Council before you go, and GOV.UK lists a return ticket and sufficient funds. With very limited ways on and off the island, the return leg is part of the plan from the start, not an afterthought.